Historical Reference

On Journeys Between Herat, and Khiva by Goldsmid

Journal of the Royal United Service Institution
VOL. XIX. 1875. No. LXXX.

LECTURE.

Page 1Page 2 - Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9 - Page 10Page 11Page 12 Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21

Page 19

This latest accession to general Oriental cartography, notwithstanding scarcely unavoidable inaccuracies and occasional vagueness of detail, merits attention as embodying much new matter. But, in asking you to accept for our present purpose a crude production, I may add that it will be my endeavor to prepare for the printed paper a map containing routes and places which have heretofore never appeared in a collective form. Major-General James Abbott, the same Officer whose journey to Khiva is now a standard reference, has kindly retraced in memory his work of 35 years ago ; and only yesterday I had the great pleasure of receiving from him a paper of almost historical value, which may be turned to account in entering new, or checking heretofore recorded stations. It is an extract from his original Field Book of a rude survey made from the saddle in 1839-40; and supplies an interesting detail of his twenty-seven marches from Herat, accomplished from the 24th December to the 19th January inclusive.

There is, no doubt, much of truth in the charge laid against England of indifference in availing herself of opportunities to advance Science, readily presented in her political field; and, as a case in point, we have been told that the presence of our Officers in Persia through very recent years, was not utilized for acquiring that knowledge of the geography of the country, notably on the Northern and North- Eastern Frontier, which we, of all nations, should seek to possess. But in blaming ourselves, as we not infrequently do, for political failures and shortcomings, might we not, at the same time, take credit for having acquired by the above-named or similar agencies, a good deal of information about Eastern and South- Eastern Persia, and Persian Baluchistan within the last ten or twenty years ? The labors of the Engineer Officers and others, attached, or otherwise associated with my late Missions, have yet to be made public, and I trust that in two or three months more, their relation in print will afford proof that the pursuit of political objects and achievements of political results have not occupied the undivided attention of British employees in Makran and Seistan. And even where opportunity has not been afforded for out-door survey and research; it is believed that a residence of so many Englishmen, and for so long a time, in Persia has not been barren in fruits of observation.

That the subject is not a popular one is no fault of theirs; nor is the fact that knowledge stored, is not knowledge used, to be visited on their heads. I can only say that so far as I can bear testimony, from some five years' experience in the superintendence of the Persian Telegraph and 2^- years in Perso-Baluch and Perso- Afghan Boundary Missions, I should have no fear for the Officers employed in either department, were they called upon to pass a competitive examination in knowledge of the country and people, with the Officers of any other service whatever. In the meanwhile, I would take the opportunity of noting that important contributions to Persian Geography •will be found in Major St. John's map in course of publication, and in the map1 illustrative of Colonel Baker's and Lieutenant Gill's explorations about to appear, I believe, in the Journal of this Institution.

1 Since published. Vide No. 79 of the Journal, Plate XVIII. — ED.

Page 1Page 2 - Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9 - Page 10Page 11Page 12 Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21

Barry O'Connell's Notes Main Index