Historical Reference

On Journeys Between Herat, and Khiva by Goldsmid

Journal of the Royal United Service Institution
VOL. XIX. 1875. No. LXXX.

LECTURE.

Page 1Page 2 - Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9 - Page 10Page 11Page 12 Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21

Page 7

tion of the city of Herat which makes it of a rectangular and nearly square form; set almost exactly after the cardinal points of the compass, the faces from north to south being somewhat longer than those from east to west, but all from 1,400 to 1,500 yards. The walls, from 24 to 20 feet high, are built on an earthen rampart of about double their own height. A deep wet ditch which surrounds the whole is supplied, according to Conolly, by springs within itself. More recent information, on the other hand, assumes it to be filled by canals outside the walls, and in such case the supply might be cut off by an enterprising invader. But M. Khanikoff mentions a more palpable obstacle to effectual defense in the existence, at the north-east angle of the walls, and at about 700 yards distance from the bastion, of a broad-crested hill, overlooking the town, and covered with solid buildings easily convertible into batteries. A mamelon of this description could hardly fail to attract the attention of an enemy even moderately skilled in the science of sieges. The “Ark," or citadel, is behind the main wall of the northern face. The “Ark-i-Nau" or new citadel, however, intervenes and overlaps the older building. There are five gates, two on the north and one at each of the other faces. A high street traverses the town from the north-west to the south gate, and is the great center of traffic. The population has been estimated at various figures. Some of these are doubtless erroneous. Others, though inapplicable to the present day, may have been tolerably correct at the time they were recorded: for the political revolutions of Herat have been continual, and must have had sensible influence on the numbers and character of the inhabitants. I do not think that 50,000 can be a very unfair or inexact supposition for the population under the Amir Sher AH. Such a total would certainly be attained if Yakub Khan or his successor could add the element of stability to successful government. Conolly, who reckoned the number of inhabitants at 45,000, added that there were 4,000 dwelling-houses, 1,200 shops, and 17 caravanserais. As the first reply to his inquiries on the spot had elicited the statement that there were 12,000 houses within the walls, it is not impossible that the reduction to less than half the figure is under the true mark. In either case, the estimate of occupants would seem to be quite sufficiently high for the occasion. The mosque, the domed reservoir, the palace of the Chahar Bagh, and, it may be, the bazaar, and one or two of the larger caravanserais may be named among the more notable monuments of Herat; and if we go beyond the walls, with these may be included the ruins on the Musalla, or place of prayer, and the tombs of the Mohammedan saint, Khajah Abdullah Ansari, and Dost Muhammad Khan.

Modern view of Herat City

In 1830, Conolly was of opinion that the city was " one of the " dirtiest in the world. Many of the small streets," he wrote, “which” branch from the main ones, are built over and form low, dark “tunnels, containing every offensive thing. No drain having been” contrived to carry off the rain which falls within the walls, it collects “and stagnates in ponds which are dug in different parts of the city.”The residents cast out the refuse of their houses into the streets,” and dead cats and dogs are commonly seen lying upon heaps of the “vilest filth."  

JBOC Notes:  Conolly's comments are interesting here. Herat was a center of world culture when London in the present UK was of small consequence. But by the 19th century it was a provincial backwater. The sea trade made the old Silk Route of little consequence and with British help Herat was wrested from Persia and given to the Pashtun rulers of Afghanistan (Treaty of Paris, 1857).

Page 1Page 2 - Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9 - Page 10Page 11Page 12 Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21

Barry O'Connell's Notes Main Index